In 1989 the Lord Chancellor approved the formation of the Judicial Committee consisting of seven senior Judges representing the English, Scottish and Northern Irish Benches.
The first version of the Model Form of Expert Report was approved by The Judicial Committee to further assist Experts and their clients by indicating a format that the Judiciary would find of assistance. In other words a “judge friendly” format.
The Model Form of Report includes the Expert's Declarations for use in Civil Proceedings (CPR), Criminal Proceedings (CrPR) and Family Proceedings (FPR). The Expert's Declaration includes the Statement of Truth.
On 30th January 2015 TAE launched a Model Form of Expert CV for use by all Experts. The Model CV format should be used in conjunction with the Model Form of Report.
A copy of the Model Form may be purchased from our online store as either a download or hard copy by post.
Extract from the Model Form:
"1. WHY A MODEL FORM?
1.1 The first version of the Model Form was introduced after some senior judges expressed concern at the length of many experts reports and at the tendency to mix matters of fact and opinion. These same concerns remain relevant today.
1.2 The Judicial Committee of the Academy has commented that the hallmarks of a good report include:-
1.2.1 a stand-alone, concise, user-friendly format, expressed in the first person singular by the person whose opinion has been given or who adopts as his own the opinion of others;
1.2.2 text which is arranged in short sentences and paragraphs;
1.2.3 judicious use of appendices;
1.2.4 matters of fact being kept separate from matters of opinion.
1.3 Conclusions should be given in the final section of the report before appendices. They should be cross referenced to the text which supports the Conclusions.
1.4 Each opinion expressed in the report must be the opinion of the writer whether it was formed by the writer or formed by others and adopted by the writer as his own.
1.5 The following must be identified separately and distinguished:-
1.5.1 facts which the writer is asked to assume;
1.5.2 facts which the writer observed for himself eg the results of experiments, investigations, etc, carried out by the writer himself;
1.5.3 facts which others, acting on behalf of the writer, observed, identifying the persons concerned;
1.5.4 opinions of others upon which the writer relies in forming his own opinion;
1.5.5 opinions of others which the writer accepts but upon which the writer cannot comment authoritatively.
1.6 The Model Form of report has been developed with these comments in mind and with the aim of assisting both experts and those instructing to address the relevant issues in the most direct way.
1.7 The model is intended as a guideline only. There may be valid reasons for departing from it and/or introducing additional sections, depending on the nature of the instructions and the dispute.
1.8 Since the Model Form was first published, new Civil and Criminal Procedure Rules have been introduced in England and Wales and other jurisdictions. These have largely taken into account the Model Form which was commended in Lord Woolf’s report “Access to Justice”. Users of the Model Form must always take care to comply with the requirements of the jurisdiction in which the report will be used."
The Judicial Committee members who worked on the original Model Form of Report were:
The Rt Hon The Lord Slynn of Hadley PC
The Rt Hon Lord Justice Neill
The Rt Hon Lord Justice Saville
The Rt Hon Lord Justice MacDermott
The Hon Lord Prosser
The Hon Mr Justice Garland
His Honour Judge Bowsher QC
In 2007, the Model Form of Expert’s report was reviewed in light of the developments that have occurred since the first version was produced. The current version takes into account the Civil Procedure Rules adopted in England and Wales, and subsequent case law applying such rules, and also the Protocol for Instruction of Experts to give Evidence in civil claims, drafted by the Civil Justice Council and approved by the Master of the Rolls.
The new version of the Model Form of Report was officially launched on 11th June 2008.
It must be remembered that the form continues to be a Model rather than a Standard.
The current version of the Model Form of Expert’s Report can equally be used in criminal proceedings by using the alternative format where suggested. The Model Form takes into account the developments encapsulated within the Criminal Procedure Rules which have also been adopted in England and Wales.
The Judicial Committee members who carried out and approved the review were:
The Rt Hon The Lord Saville of Newdigate
President of The Academy of Experts
Chairman of the Committee
Hon Mr Justice Bokary
Court of Final Appeal Hong Kong
The Rt Hon Lady Justice Hallett
Court of Appeal
The Hon Lord Johnston
Court of Session Scotland
The Hon Mr Justice Bean
Queens Bench Division
The Hon Mr Justice Jackson
Queens Bench Division
Clerk to the Committee
The Committee was greatly assisted in its work preparing the current version of the Model Form of Expert’s Report by:
Committee Secretary for the project
Eversheds LLP, Solicitors
Assistant Committee Secretary
Eversheds LLP, Solicitors
Practising Expert Member